College Media Network

Church leader pushes for gay acceptance

Julia Butler

Print this article

Published: Thursday, October 2, 2008

Updated: Thursday, October 2, 2008

church

Shannon Young

Father Paul Bresnahan addresses the topic of sexual identity and the Anglican Church Wednesday night.

After growing up under the guidance of his uncle, a gay, blue-collar worker from Somerville, Father Paul Bresnahan of St. Peter's Episcopal Church in Salem said he was raised to love all people, regardless of their sexual orientation and called for the religious recognition, acceptance and celebration of homosexuality.

Bresnahan spoke about the Episcopalian Church's views on homosexuality at the Church of St. John the Evangelist on Bowdoin Street Wednesday night.

Bresnahan said he hopes there will be a day when all religions come together and accept homosexuality. 

"There has to be a time when folks of the Book and folks of religious traditions all recognize that there's room in God's love for everyone," he said.

Bresnahan said he became a strong proponent of inclusiveness in the church after observing firsthand the relationship between his uncle and his uncle's male partner.

"The only person in my family to have a stable relationship was my gay uncle," he said.

Bresnahan recalled seeing his uncle Al come home after being beaten by people who did not understand Al's sexual orientation.

"When my uncle died, I officiated the funeral," he said. "There was only one person in attendance. It was his partner of 50 years, and it was just a breathtakingly beautiful moment. That was when I became deeply wedded to the idea that the church has to grow up."

Bresnahan said the church focuses on the subject of homosexuality too much, and in doing so ignores more the important issues.

"We are all being distracted from all these other issues, like the environment, by the question of whether people can love each other," he said. "It's daft."

 Bresnahan acknowledged that many different religious denominations struggle with acceptance of homosexuality, but he said the struggle was necessary for the church to keep up with the times.

 "It's going to be tough, but the world will teach the church," he said. "The world is going way ahead of us, and we need to catch [up] or be left behind."

Bresnahan's gay son, David Bresnahan, introduced his father at the event and spoke of his gratitude for the acceptance his family has given him and called his father his "personal hero."

"I feel very fortunate that it's always been a non-issue," he said. "I definitely consider myself pretty lucky."

David said he is optimistic for the future of the church, and its relationship with its lesbian, gay, bisexual and transgender members.

 "I really think that we're already moving in a progressive way," David said. "We're moving in a way to purposefully be inclusive of all people, and I think it opens the doors to all sorts of people to use their gifts to help their community."

Elaine Cronin, who attended the event because the topic interested her, said she supported the message of inclusivity in the church.

"No matter what their sexuality, race or religion, we have a moral obligation to include them."

Comments

20 comments
Lesley
Wed Jan 7 2009 13:33
Nice article. For me it comes down to choosing Love over Judgment. As we grow we learn that it is not necessary to equate difference with sin (now being left-handed is acceptable.) We learn that it is not necessary to equate social mores of the first century with eternal reality (now we do not tolerate slavery or the subjugation of women.) Soon we will learn to accept GLBT folks with love and not reject them with 'judgment'.
Mike
Sun Oct 19 2008 11:21
Amazing. In a time when sin is all around us, we condemn those who are not in alignment with our own personal beliefs - beliefs which are born out of interpretation after interpretation after interpretation.

Love, everyone. Just Love. Do not cast the first stone.

Arnoldas
Fri Oct 17 2008 06:53
Faith is not just knowing and espousing the fact of one's religion but obeying the Great Truths those facts are ultimately conveying. When a man separates these two things, he's caught in amn array of weird ideas, like the one preast is here suggesting - follow the World which is teaching the Church about its Faith.
Anthony
Fri Oct 10 2008 17:56
It's amazing how some people who are gay say that the day will come when the church loves and accepts all. Whoa, hold the phone! Jesus did that then. The church does it now. If you are "born" homosexual, but you want to follow God, then either God has to change you, or maybe you have to remain "alone". The onus is on God, not you, to change you from within. Why do the gay people limit God's power by assuming that He can't; maybe He will; maybe He won't; the gays who fight this demonstrate that they have not read the power nor do they subscribe to God's authority of the bible. God can do what He wants with you (does the clay tell the Potter what to do??!!), but no matter what He does--you follow Him. Not men's thinking; God's thinking. If you are serious about serving God, He will either change you or you will remain gay, but in any event, you can have no sexual relationship with another member of your own sex. The bible does not endorse the acts of homosexuality--at all! If you follow God--gay or not--you are a retired sinner. All believers are retired sinners; that's the idea of victory over sin.
Spook
Mon Oct 6 2008 13:48
The "end times" have been on us for the last 2000 years. Every generation cries out about the end times. It's never come. When you follow all the laws of Leviticus, ALL OF THEM, and not just pick and choose which parts of the Bible to follow, then you can decry homosexuality as "wrong".
Nerak
Mon Oct 6 2008 13:23
It is very sad that you people are so blinded by your faith you ignore the true issues of the world. I am not a christian, I believe the concept of building a giant ark full of two of every animal is ludacris as well as the woman being made from the rib of the man. Honestly, if the woman gives birth than how is it we are created by the man?
I respect religion to the point where they begin the unhealthy juding of people. If any of you care to prove you're point that it's a choice, you need to argue with the scientific reasearch that has been done to prove differances in genetics and brain chemicals. Regardless of that, have you ever stopped and thought why someone would CHOOSE to be looked down upon and treated badly by people such as yourselves?
Why don't you grow up and look outside of the box.
We're not living in the stone ages anymore
Brian
Fri Oct 3 2008 19:18
I am afraid that the end times are upon us all. God loves all of us his children. God is not angry but sad with those who sin. Homosexuals want acceptance and they may find some in this world but come the next it will be very different. The homosexuals think that with acceptance they will be happy but it will be empty. the only way to find peace is to allow the Holy Spirit to come in and clean the heart. They say that "God made me this way" No God did not make you that way you chose that way. We must all pray for these times and that God's truth will prevail.
Henry Butler
Fri Oct 3 2008 17:39
The church as I know it today does not discriminate against anyone. We are sinners all. However, the controversy in the Episcopal Church is not about membership or participation, it is about the fact that the leadership has turned away from bibical teachings on every front, subverted the very meaning of the Episcopal Church, and has insisted on incorporating homosexuals into the leadership of the church as role models, i.e. the bishop of New Hampshire...this is totally unacceptable to members of the traditional denomination.
chiefpayne
Fri Oct 3 2008 16:55
God does love us all...but that does NOT mean He loves and accepts everything we do. God loves us and wants us to obey His word...and that does NOT mean engaging in homosexual activities. Homosexuality is a sin and like it or not, God does not want His children doing it. So while we accept the sinner as a child of God, we do not accept the sin as acceptable behavior because it is a sin in the eyes of God!
Ozark_Sunshine
Fri Oct 3 2008 15:16
Yes we are to love the sinner and hate the sin, but the Bible tells us that to be a Christian you have to turn from sin and that's why homosexuals aren't Christian. They refuse to "Go and sin no more." This doesn't mean that a sinner won't ever commit the sin again, but homosexuals never even try turning from their sin. This church leader needs to be removed from authority because he thinks his words are God's word and because he teaches these lies, he is leading people astray. He will be held accountable, just like the homosexuals.
Momma
Fri Oct 3 2008 13:21
Thank you, John, for providing those verses. 2 Peter 2 especially pricked my thoughts and heart today.

I'm sad that men like Paul Bresnahan are obfuscating condemnation of sin with condemnation of the sinner. We are all sinners, and God's love is for everyone. But, God hates our sins, and we must lift each other up to fight against our sins, not to try to make them appear normal and palatable.

Maria
Fri Oct 3 2008 12:56
Love the sinner, hate the sin.
Jeff
Fri Oct 3 2008 12:37
Most Christians already recognize that God has enough love for everyone. Like an earthly parent, God loves his children even if they don't love him or do wrong. That doesn't mean those disbelievers or violators of God's laws won't face judgement. God is love, but He is also just. Any sin, homosexuality or something else, cannot be 'embraced' and made okay. The ignorance of the Episcopal leadership on Biblical law is baffling. We are forgiven for our sins through Christ, but continuing in sin, even celebrating it, is evidence these people don't really know Christ.
Truth
Fri Oct 3 2008 12:02
There is a special place in Hell for apostate priets like this one who have the power to pursuade many and who use it to lead them astray. God have mercy on him.
Joshua
Fri Oct 3 2008 11:49
Catch up with the world???? This heretic priest wants the church to catch up with the world?? Has he read the bible?? We are not supposed to be caught up in the works of the world. What a disgrace!!
Bobby
Fri Oct 3 2008 11:47
If God accepts homesexuality, then then He needs to raise all the people is Sodom and Gomorrah and apologize. This is what happens when we look to the world rather the God.
Br. Dale Brown, C.J.
Fri Oct 3 2008 10:36
God have mercy on shepherds like this one, who lead God's children away from Him in their heresies. Homosexuality is a sin and this man is endangering people's eternal lives. Everyone please know that this man does not represent but a very small segment of the Anglican World. He is part of a small sect of 60's generation leaders who are still trying to fuse together an antiquated modernist philosophy with religion and making a jumbled mess of it all. God have mercy on us all through His Son Jesus Christ.
Renee
Fri Oct 3 2008 08:15
John,

Amen to that!

Your name
Fri Oct 3 2008 06:22
This man desperately needs to read what has been hailed (by the likes of ex-gay preacher, Stephen Bennett) to be one of the most comprehensive books on homosexuality that covers all Bible texts -- from Genesis to Revelation -- in chronological order, with the modern "gay" interpretation of the texts compared with what the original language and context actually say. The book is "Homosexuality and the Bible" by Gerald N. Wright (Star Bible). "A must for all Bible students, preachers and those struggling or debating this issue."
John
Fri Oct 3 2008 04:22
If the book that the "father" is referring to is the bible, maybe he should spend some time reading it, like Romans 1:27, 1 Timothy 1:10-11, and 2 Samuel 1:26 for starters. Sure, it is true that God is a God of love, BUT, God is also holy and just and HATES sins.
He did offer a way to him by sending his son, Jesus Christ to die on the cross to pay for our sins. But in order to be accepted by him is to repent and turn away from our sins, not accept and glorify it.
He should also read 2 Peter 2

Log in Log in to be able to post comments.